Orange school board approves health insurance hikes, angering teachers

Orlando Sentinel | By: Steven Walker | November 13, 2026

 

A divided Orange County School Board approved hikes to employee health insurance plans on Friday after an eight-hour hearing, saying the move was needed to shore up its insurance funds’ looming $145 million deficit caused by surging costs.

The decision, approved by a 5-3 vote, angered the local teachers union and infuriated teachers watching the meeting online as the new plans amount to a pay cut for many.

Teachers will get raises of 1.98% to 2.65% but the cost of their health insurance premiums and deductibles will go up more steeply. Under one of the district’s most popular plans, for example, deductibles increase for individuals from $300 to $2,000 and for families from $600 to $4,000.

Jeff Mendel, a district attorney, told the school board that increasing premiums and deductibles was needed to keep OCPS’ self-insured fund solvent. With the higher prices, the fund would be self-sustaining for the first time in 10 years. The costs of the insurance fund have increased by 76% in the last 10 years, but revenues from employee premiums have only increased by about 28%, according to district data. The district has moved money from reserves to shore up the fund.

“There’s no two ways about it. Based upon the numbers, I think we don’t have a choice,” Mendel said.

But the higher costs prompted a months-long battle with the Orange County Classroom Teachers Association, which argued the district was wrongly solving its financial problems by hurting teachers, the backbone of its workforce.

Friday’s hearing was the culmination of that fight that began in April when OCPS declared impasse in its contract negotiations, saying the district and its teachers union could not reach an agreement on health insurance costs.

The union then sought recommendations from a special magistrate — appointed to evaluate proposals from both sides and issue non-binding recommendations. The magistrate recommended a compromise that would have hiked employee insurance costs but more moderately.

The union accepted that suggestion, but district staff did not, putting the decision to the school board, which heard hours of argument from both sides before it voted Friday evening.

Both district staff and the five board members who voted to impose the plan said that the magistrate’s proposal would still cost OCPS about $105 million, far too much for a school district already struggling with budget problems stemming from declining enrollment and rising costs.

Clinton McCracken, the union’s president, said he was “disappointed” in the board’s ultimate decision.

“Shame on our School Board!!” one teacher wrote on Facebook after the meeting.

Teachers will get to vote on the plan, but if they do not ratify it, it still goes into effect for one year.

Chair Teresa Jacobs and board members Melissa Byrd, Alicia Farrant, Vicki-Elaine Felder and Maria Salamanca voted for the plan that hiked employee premiums and deductibles.

Farrant said the changes were overdue, as the district’s deficit has existed for years.

Because of rising health insurance costs nationwide, the OCPS insurance fund has not been self supporting, with the district transferring another $20 million into it just this month, officials said.

“This is something that has actually been going on for the last four years, and I believe we’re in this predicament because it has been kicked down the road every single year,” Farrant said.

Farrant, Jacobs and Salamanca leave the board this month.

Board members Anne Douglas, Angie Gallo, who will soon be the board chair, and Stephanie Vanos voted against it.

Gallo said she wanted to see if an estimated $40 million payment from settling lawsuits with Walt Disney World over excessive property tax assessments could soften the blow of deductible increases for this upcoming year — a proposal the union supported.

But the district’s attorneys cautioned the board against using that Disney money as a way to solve the health insurance impasse.

“It doesn’t address the underlying issues with respect to the health insurance trust, and essentially we are just pushing the issue down the road. At some point in time, there has to be a reckoning,” Mendel said.

The full board agreed, however, that it would get that $40 million to teachers in the form of salary supplements, though details are not yet finalized.

Members of the Orange County Classroom Teachers Association (OCCTA) listen to the discussion with the Orange County School Board during a day-long special impasse meeting, Friday, Nov. 13, 2026. The OCCTA and the district are in a months-long dispute, primarily over employee health insurance costs.

Before the board voted, Samantha Lindstrom, a math teacher, was among the union supporters who urged the board to accept the magistrate’s compromise.

Her daughter had a medical scare over the summer that racked up about $12,000 in medical bills, she said. Under the current insurance plan, she paid only about $1,200. But under one of the district’s proposed plans, she would’ve paid for the whole bill, she said.

Her daughter still needs more tests and the district’s proposal would be “devastating,” Lindstrom said.

“I have already updated my resume and have been applying for jobs in and outside of education because I will not be able to make it until the end of the year, if the district proposal is chosen,” Lindstrom said.

Union leaders also said their district counterparts would not consider other options.

“We brought multiple cost-saving alternatives to the table that should have been implemented before shifting such enormous costs onto employees. Almost all were rejected,” McCracken said.

But Salamanca said the parties met 20 times over the course of the impasse and the union did not provide a viable alternative.

She disputed the claims of Mark Richard, the union’s attorney, that the district showed “no imagination.”

“Mr. Richard, you show up today with new ideas and imagination, and it’s really difficult to address and do some of these numbers on the moment of the impasse,” Salamanca said.

The board acted as the judge in the labor dispute, but it was not an impartial one. The board approved the budget that set parameters for the negotiations with the union and is the boss of Superintendent Maria Vazquez, whose staff wanted to impose the changes.

Richard told Vazquez her administration had left OCPS teachers “depressed” about their work.

“Maria, you’ve lost the crew. You’re head of a team that nobody wants to play on anymore,” he said.

Share With:
Rate This Article